“A Texan Looks at Lyndon”, Robert Caro, and the Illegitimacy of Mainstream Intellectualism

While those in the research community are open to many uncomfortable truths behind our country’s hidden history, primarily political assassinations, most mainstream academics and historians patently reject conspiracy in the assassinations of the ’60s, especially the killing of JFK.

However, recently a couple of friends who are respected academics – one a dean at a small liberal arts college and the other a chair at a major private university – read mainstream historian Robert Caro’s series of in-depth biographies of LBJ.  They both came away fully believing that LBJ was capable of all of the crimes and murders attributed to him over the years, especially the possible complicity – either explicit or tacit – in the assassination of JFK.

Since 1963, the subjects of my film – researchers of political assassinations – have known all of the facts expressed in mainstream histories of those events, and have included those facts in publication after publication over the years. Regarding LBJ, the 1964 book, A Texan Looks At Lyndon: A Study in Illegitimate Power, by J. Evetts Haley, Texan Looks at Lyndon book pic 1revealed every single fact about LBJ that Caro used. But Haley was an average citizen, not a mainstream academic like Caro.  Independent researchers like Haley have suffered ridicule and have been pushed to the intellectual margins of American society; that should be unacceptable to each and every one of us.

My larger point should be clear: mainstream academics accept facts of only fellow mainstream academics, and mainstream media only accepts agreed upon facts by other mainstream media sources. We’ve seen this over and over again.  Why do we rely on publications like the NY Times, the Washington Post or the Wall Street Journal as final arbiters of accepted thought? Why don’t we trust research methods over blind institutional acceptance?  I fear that until we consumers of information re-evaluate the sources upon which we rely to interpret our collective history, we are doomed to repeat it.

A New Year’s message from the late John Judge

Screen Shot 2017-11-30 at 1.10.50 PM

A New Year’s message from the late John Judge, co-founder & former director of COPA.

“And We Are All Mortal…”, American University, June 10, 2014

Screen Shot 2017-11-30 at 12.43.32 PMEvery June 10th at 12:00 noon, the Coalition on Political Assassinations has held a commemoration of John F. Kennedy’s American University address, also known as his “Peace Speech“, at Peace Speech Memorial on the campus of American U.  First held in 1999 by COPA co-founders John Judge and Bill Kelly, and longtime COPA board member, T Carter, a small collection of seasoned researchers and interested citizens, led by COPA Director John Judge, have gathered annually to honor JFK and reflect on his vision for peace, which was delivered less than 6 months before his assassination.

I’m sure all are now aware of the recent passing of John.  A devastating loss not only to his friends, but to the research community as well.  While no one can possibly replace John, we friends and supporters of COPA felt passionate that John’s commemoration of JFK’s speech should continue. This year, however, we would also be honoring John, and his life spent fighting for the same vision of peace expressed in JFK’s speech.

On June 10, 2014, I was honored to lead COPA’s 16th “And We Are All Mortal…” Annual Commemoration of JFK’s American University Peace Speech.  Joining me was Deborah Cunningham, Pat Simon, Assassination Archives and Research Center (ARRC) Founder & President Jim Lesar, AARC Director Jerry Policoff, Karl Golovin and Chris Hager.   The morning was sunny and warm, a typical beautiful DC summer day.  But as the time got closer to 12 noon, the skies slowly grew darker and darker.  At 12:00, the sky opened up, and we were caught in a downpour. It’s as if the gods saw us standing there at the memorial and chose to test our mettle and dedication.  Once the rain started, I couldn’t help think of something John said to me in Dallas last November at the 50th: It was a rainy and bitterly cold day. We were all miserable. As my freezing fingers were fumbling with my camera, John walked up and told the story about how JFK’s press corps had a joke that wherever JFK went, the weather was always beautiful. The press corps would say, “It’s a Kennedy day”!  John looked around at everyone, cold and wet, and said, “this is no Kennedy day”.

That day at American was no Kennedy day, either.

Instead of attempting to give the commemoration myself, I instead played the audio from John’s presentation in 2003.  Infinitely better than anything I could have possibly come up with.

I wrapped up our commemoration with the following:

It’s telling that we’re standing here on the campus of an elite university in the nation’s capital, and who’s here? Just us. No students, no politicians, no press, and, most telling, no historians. John addressed this perfectly in footage I use in the opening of my film, The Searchers:  “What died on November 22, 1963, was more than just a president. Truth was killed. Hope was killed. And a government that responded to popular movements was killed. But we in the US are what’s left of democracy in the world. We have more potential of any country to make democracy work. We have a strength that the powers in this country are afraid of. But if you want a democracy you have to make it a democracy. And the first step is to take back your history.”




A Celebration of the Life of John Judge May 31, 2014

Screen Shot 2017-11-30 at 12.57.29 PM

On May 31, 2014, a Celebration of Life for John Judge was held at the National Press Club in Washington, DC. Speaking first, among the featured speakers, was Dennis Kucinich.  The celebration was organized by John’s longtime life partner Marilyn Tenenoff, the love of his life.

Memorial for John Judge, by Andrew Kreig, June 1, 2014

Memorial for Civic Activist John Judge Sustains His Legacy

John JudgeTwo hundred friends and admirers of the late civic activist and historical researcher John P. Judge fostered his legacy during a memorial service May 31 at the National Press Club in Washington, DC.

Former Ohio Congressman Dennis Kucinich (D), a next door neighbor and close friend, described Judge as an extraordinary truth-seeker in the spirit of the ancient Diogenes. Kucinich continued, “What better place for it than Washington, DC — the capital of smoke and mirrors?”

Kucinich, 67, was a longtime member of the House until 2013 who said he often benefited from Judge’s insights about why American democracy and the economy have deteriorated in recent decades. Kucinich said he intends to keep hundreds of emails from Judge on current and historic events. “One day, they’ll be put to good use.”

Other eloquent tributes followed. Judge died April 15 at age 66 following a stroke two months previously.

Speakers portrayed, sometimes using music or photos, how the Washington-reared only son of two doting Department of Defense employees embarked on a lifelong quest to explore the nation’s “hidden history.” The search began during his days as a student at University of Dayton beginning in 1965, just as the Vietnam War was ratcheting up.

Judge’s late mother had been a Pentagon specialist in planning to fulfill the nation’s personnel needs via the draft. One of Judge’s disclosures was that his mother, Mary Cooley Judge, was instructed just three days after Kennedy assassination to revise upward the Pentagon’s personnel needs for the Vietnam War-era draft under incoming President Lyndon Johnson.

In a 1992 speech at American University cable cast on C-SPAN’s “JFK: Cinema as History,” Judge recalled, “They [the Joint Chiefs of Staff] told her on Nov. 25, 1963 that the war in Vietnam would last for 10 years and that 57,000 Americans would die, and to figure that in.”

Judge’s major effort of recent years was leading the Coalition on Political Assassinations (COPA), which showcased serious alternatives to official accounts of the JFK assassination and such other notable deaths during the 1960s as those of Robert Kennedy, Malcolm X and the Rev. Martin Luther King Jr.

Judge presided at COPA’s 20th annual conference last November in Dallas, which I attended for three days along with 300 other researchers. The focus was on the 50th anniversary of President Kennedy’s assassination. The program’s title was “50 Years is Enough! Free the Files, Find the Truth.”

Dealey Plaza Panorama (Andrew Kreig Photo)

The conference featured medical, security, investigative and other experts challenging various aspects of the 1964 Warren Commission Report. In its 1964 report that closely tracked immediate announcements after the death, the commissioners blamed the killing on Lee Harvey Oswald. The report claimed that Oswald acted alone and fired all shots from the sixth floor of the Texas Book Depository Building.

The book building is the one at left of my photo of Dealey Plaza, shot during the conference. The Warren Commission stated that Oswald was in the square window at the building’s far right, second from the top. The light-colored car in the middle lane is in the approximate location of the JFK limo when the president was fatally hit.

Other experts and witnesses believe shots were fired from at least one other location, and perhaps several others that include the locale from behind a picket fence at the top of the grassy knoll in the photo at leftDealey Plaza Picket Fence (Andrew Kreig Photo).

The fence is still in place, as indicated in the other photo. As indicated, an unknown person or persons has repeatedly and surreptitiously painted a cross on the street to mark the limo’s locale when the fatal bullet struck. In the spirit of the “Out damned spot” scene in MacBeth, Dallas authorities have kept obliterating the mark.

Judge’s best estimate, he has told interviewers, was the Joint Chiefs of Staff played a role in organizing the JFK killing and a cover-up. “I don’t think this is an insoluble parlor mystery,” he once told the Dallas Morning News.

Speakers at the memorial included David Ratcliffe, who authored a book on special operations during the Vietnam War. It drew on the insights of retired Air Force Col. L. Fletcher Prouty, Defense Department Chief of Special Operations and liaison to the CIA during the Kennedy administration.

Before his death in 2001, Prouty provided his views in two books, The Secret Team (1973) and JFK: The CIA, Vietnam and the Plot to Assassinate John F. Kennedy (1996). In the latter, Prouty provided many specifics in arguing that the CIA was instrumental in planning the JFK assassination and a cover-up on behalf of elite figures who benefited from $6 trillion in war spending between 1945 and the subsequent half century. Prouty wrote that Kennedy had intended to withdraw U.S. troops from Vietnam, smash the CIA “into a thousand pieces” in actions that the military-industrial complex would not tolerate. Prouty argued that Oswald was a “patsy” framed in advance to avoid investigation of the real killers, and that all presidents after JFK have learned, just like the Warren Commission and the media, to go along with the agenda’s of what Prouty called the nation’s elite, also known as a “High Cabal” or “Secret Team.”

As described by Ratcliffe, Judge’s work ranged across many cutting-edge issues. In 1985, he co-founded CHOICES, a group countering military recruitment in DC-area high schools. He and his colleagues counseled students on their options in the military and elsewhere.

As an aide to Georgia Congresswoman Cynthia McKinney, he helped her prepare articles of impeachment against President George W. Bush for, among other things, initiating war against Iraq under the false claim that Iraq had been developing weapons of mass destruction. She introduced the articles in December 2006.

“A conversation with John,” his friend Joseph Green recalled, “was like talking to the best and most entertaining professor you ever had.” Others described Judge as optimistic and joyful even in seeking to illuminate dark deeds with slender finances because “he rarely sought or received” compensation for his public interest work.

At the time of his death, John Judge was working to create a Hidden History Library and Research Center. He intended to preserve his collection of thousands of books and documents and to educate a new generation. According to his bio, “He hoped to support the work of investigative researchers looking into the National Security State, the rise of secrecy, threats to civil liberties, government plans for extra-Constitutional jurisdiction during emergencies, and the ever-increasing power of the military industrial complex.”

His companion and other friends are currently sorting through their best options to achieve those results.

The spirit of the memorial was captured by Judge’s friend Patrick Elder, a longtime colleague in the peace movement.

“We’ve lost John Judge!” Elder said he heard last April.

In reflecting on a powerful life’s work and an inspirational memorial, Elder told the audience a better view is, “We haven’t lost him. We’re just finding him. Have you ever felt John more alive?!”

John Judge: A Remembrance by David Ratcliffe May 31, 2014

Support Justice for Abraham Bolden

John Judge: We Are Responsible

Screen Shot 2017-11-30 at 12.46.34 PM

This is an excerpt from a video entitled: “John Judge: Judge for Yourself Part 2”. This short segment illustrates what an amazing person John was, and what an inspiration he will always be.

“But I know what human existence is worth. I know who we are at the deepest level.
I know what we can offer each other. I exist in a society that most of my life has totally ignored, the worth of people around me, and I feel it’s my responsibility, duty bound, to reverse that direction.”


Searcher John Judge’s Counter-recruitment

Screen Shot 2017-11-30 at 12.54.43 PM

John Judge worked tirelessly, not just researching political assassinations, but in countering what he called “the poverty draft” the military machine wages in inner city schools.

Searcher John Judge Moment of Silence 2013